Il Classico

The Chocolate Chip cookie was still soft in the middle and had just the right amount of salt to balance the sweetness. The Frosted Oatmeal one surprised me too, since the icing actually stayed put instead of melting everywhere. This box is perfect for a long week of office snacks.

The box itself is beautiful, but the cookies are the real star—the chocolate chip was perfectly soft and the frosted oatmeal had just the right amount of icing. I've already eaten three of the six, which says everything about how good they are.

The assortment box itself is sturdy enough that the Frosted Oatmeal arrived perfectly intact, and the packaging makes it easy to grab one on the go. Would've liked a bit more variety in the flavors, but for a classic lineup it hits the spot.